On Monday night, “Pretty Little Liars” wrapped up after a super-successful, what-will-happen-next first season. Shay Mitchell, who plays lovable lesbian Emily on the hit drama, admitted that when she watched the episode along with fellow “PLL”er Ashley Benson (both pictured), she was pretty surprised.

Last night, I watched it with Ashley, and honestly, there were a couple screaming moments,” she told Hollywood Crush. “For me, I totally forgot about Lucas picking up Caleb and even the whole moving thing with Emily. I can see why fans are shocked. It was intense and well-shot [to show] the whole intenseness of it all.

I love the fact that Florence and the Machine was playing as the song at the end,” she continued. “For me, because I had seen what was shot of course, I would have said the whole thing with Spencer and Ian [was shocking for fans]. For me it was Melissa and Spencer’s car accident [that was shocking]. Ashley looked over at me and was like, ‘Are you serious?’ We turned off the lights and everything. I was genuinely freaked out.”

In the end, a possible A contender ended up dead, but as quickly as [SPOILER ALERT] Ian died, his body went missing. So, is he even really dead? “Again you never know… I would think he is dead,” she said. “But who knows? That was pretty intense.”

With no new episodes until June, when the new season kicks off, Shay shared what she’d like to see happen next. “There’s so many other things about A and who that is, and that’s a person that knows so much about each and every one of them—A affects all of us,” she said. “Obviously all of us girls would love to know who A is. I don’t know if we’ll find that out next season. We’ve been totally removed from everything.”

What did you think of last night’s “Pretty Little Liars” finale? Do you think Ian is actually dead? What would you like to see happen next season? Tell us in the comments and on Twitter!